Crypto Guru
RegulationFull story · 4 min read

Louisiana judge restrains Kalshi, Coinbase and others in prediction-market gambling case

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill sued Kalshi, Polymarket, Coinbase, Crypto.com, Gemini, Robinhood and other prediction-market operators in state court on 12 November, alleging they run unlicensed online gambling. A judge in Tangipahoa Parish granted a temporary restraining order the same evening, local broadcaster WBRZ reported. Louisiana is the 11th US state to take prediction markets to court as the fight over state versus federal oversight widens.

Louisiana has become the latest US state to take prediction markets to court, and this time the list of targets reaches well beyond specialist betting sites into some of the best-known names in crypto. Attorney General Liz Murrill filed suit in state court on Thursday, 12 November, accusing a group of platforms of running unlicensed online gambling in the state. By that evening a judge had granted a temporary restraining order against them, local broadcaster WBRZ reported.

Who is named in the case

According to WBRZ, the petition was filed in the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish and names twelve companies. Alongside the prediction-market specialists Kalshi, Polymarket's US arm (QCX), ForecastEx, Novig and ProphetX, it lists the crypto exchanges Coinbase, Crypto.com (through its US entity Foris DAX) and Gemini, as well as Robinhood, Underdog, the derivatives venue Nadex and its owner IG Group. The Block counted ten platforms, and the first report by WAFB named five. The gap appears to come from how parent companies and subsidiaries were counted; the WBRZ list is the most detailed so far.

The state wants an injunction and civil penalties. Its core argument is that event contracts, which pay out depending on whether something happens, are bets in all but name. The filing points to contracts on which party will control the Senate, who the next White House press secretary will be, Oscar winners, Federal Reserve rate decisions and college football. After the order, Murrill said illegal gambling is a crime, and accused the operators of trying to make up new words to dodge gaming laws, regulators and taxes.

The reports published so far do not name the judge or set out the exact terms of the order, and none of the companies had commented publicly in the coverage we reviewed. Robinhood has said its event contracts are regulated by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) and offered through its derivatives subsidiary, The Block noted. Louisiana First News reported that the state is seeking both a restraining order and a longer-term injunction.

A widening state-versus-federal fight

The case is the newest front in a long-running dispute over who regulates these products. Platforms such as Kalshi argue that because their contracts are listed on CFTC-regulated exchanges, federal law overrides state gambling rules. States reply that sports and novelty contracts are gambling that needs a state licence. The Block counts Louisiana as the 11th state to sue prediction markets: Arkansas filed its own case on 5 November, which Crypto Guru covered, Utah brought criminal charges against Kalshi and its co-founders in late October, and Connecticut acted in August.

Louisiana's move also follows a pre-emptive step by Kalshi. Last month the company sued Governor Jeff Landry, Murrill and members of the state Gaming Control Board in federal court, asking a judge to stop the state applying its gambling laws to its sports contracts. The state court order now sits alongside that federal case, which could leave operators facing conflicting rulings until a higher court settles the question.

Pressure is building in Washington too. CNBC reported this week that the CFTC is examining whether Kalshi properly self-certified some contracts, according to The Block, and Reuters reported in October that the agency is looking at Polymarket over a 2022 settlement. Crypto Guru reported on the CFTC's warning to Kalshi earlier this week.

Why crypto exchanges are exposed

For Coinbase, Crypto.com and Gemini, prediction markets have become a small but growing side business while ordinary trading volumes fall. Gemini's quarterly results, released the same day, showed prediction-market revenue of about $800,000 (roughly R13.4 million), up 52% from the previous quarter, against exchange revenue of $13.4 million (about R225 million), The Block reported. The sums are modest, but the Louisiana case shows that adding these products can draw an exchange into conflict with state gambling authorities, not only financial regulators. How courts resolve the federal-versus-state question could decide whether US platforms can keep offering such contracts nationwide.

WHAT IT MEANS FOR AFRICA

The direct link to South Africa is limited, but it exists. Local exchange Luno lists prediction markets among its retail products, alongside tokenised stocks and staking, according to MyBroadband. Whether these contracts are treated as financial products or as gambling is exactly what Louisiana is now testing in court. We found no public statement from the FSCA or provincial gambling boards on that question so far.

Elsewhere, the Louisiana order is a state court ruling that applies within that state, and none of the reporting suggests the platforms' services outside the US are affected. For African customers of the global apps run by Coinbase, Crypto.com or Gemini, the case matters mainly as a signal of how authorities are starting to draw lines around a product that crypto exchanges increasingly want to sell.

SOURCES

MORE FROM CRYPTO GURU

← All the latest crypto news