Judge acquits Peraire-Bueno brothers in $25 million Ethereum MEV case, ending retrial plans
A federal judge in Manhattan acquitted Anton and James Peraire-Bueno on Monday of wire fraud and related charges over an April 2023 trade that took more than $25 million (about R424 million) from automated Ethereum trading bots in seconds. Judge Jessica Clarke found prosecutors had not shown a material misrepresentation, which wire fraud requires. The ruling follows a November 2025 mistrial after the jury deadlocked, and removes the need for a second trial.
One of the most closely watched crypto criminal cases in the United States has ended without a conviction. On Monday 16 November, US District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno, both educated at MIT, of wire fraud and the related charges they faced over a 2023 Ethereum trade, The Block reported. Prosecutors had said the pair took more than $25 million, about R424 million at today's rate of roughly R16.98 to the dollar, from automated trading bots. The judge concluded that the government had not shown the kind of lie that federal wire fraud law requires.
What the brothers did
The case turns on a corner of crypto known as MEV, short for maximal extractable value. On Ethereum, transactions wait in a public queue before they are added to a block, and whoever orders them can profit from that ordering. Specialised programs called sandwich bots watch the queue, buy a token just ahead of someone else's large purchase and sell straight after it, pocketing the price move they helped cause.
According to the original charges, in April 2023, about seven months after Ethereum moved to proof of stake, the brothers ran their own validator and used a flaw in MEV-Boost, widely used software that connects validators with specialised block builders. Prosecutors said they placed bait transactions that lured the bots into large trades, then used early sight of the bots' bundles to reorder the block and swap in their own transactions, taking more than $25 million in about 12 seconds, The Block reported at the time of the trial. The pair were arrested in May 2024 and charged with wire fraud, conspiracy to commit wire fraud and conspiracy to commit money laundering.
From hung jury to acquittal
The first trial ended in a mistrial in November 2025 after several weeks of evidence, when jurors could not agree on a verdict, according to Cointelegraph. Prosecutors had framed the scheme as a bait and switch that deceived the bots' operators. The defence argued that the brothers had simply out-competed other traders in a rough, open market where bots try to exploit each other all the time. Peter Van Valkenburgh of the advocacy group Coin Center called the prosecution a massive overstep.
Within days, US Attorney Jay Clayton asked Judge Clarke for a retrial as early as late February or March 2026, The Block reported. Instead, the defence pressed a motion to throw out the charges. At a hearing in March, reported by DL News, James Peraire-Bueno's lawyer Patrick Looby argued that the fraud case lacked a promise the brothers had broken and pointed to the earlier acquittal of Avraham Eisenberg in the Mango Markets case. Prosecutor Danielle Kudla countered that the case was about deception, citing the MEV-Boost specification and the fact that Flashbots patched the flaw within a day. Judge Clarke said then that she would rule before setting a new trial date.
Her ruling, as summarised by The Block and Grafa, is that the evidence did not show material misrepresentations. Without a false statement, there is no wire fraud, and the related conspiracy charges fell with it. ChainCatcher's account adds that the judge also noted the trades did not take place in a regulated market. Initial reports did not say whether prosecutors plan to appeal.
Why the ruling matters
The decision does not say that what the brothers did was fair or harmless. The bot operators still lost money, and a civil claim is a separate question. But it narrows how far US prosecutors can stretch general fraud law to cover aggressive on-chain trading where no one was told anything false. Supporters of the brothers argue that blockchains are open systems in which software follows its own rules and bots are expected to defend themselves. Critics counter that deliberately exploiting a software flaw to take others' money should carry consequences even without a lie. The ruling, together with the Eisenberg outcome, could make prosecutors more cautious about similar cases, and may push lawmakers and regulators to write rules aimed directly at market manipulation on decentralised platforms.
WHAT IT MEANS FOR AFRICA
The direct link to South Africa and the rest of the continent is small. We found no reporting that African traders or bot operators were among those who lost money in the 2023 trade, and the ruling applies only in a US court. The broader question it raises, how to treat harmful conduct on decentralised platforms that sit outside licensing regimes, is one African regulators are also facing. In a lecture reported by ITWeb, FSCA Commissioner Unathi Kamlana said the regulator has a workable perimeter for centralised crypto businesses but that DeFi increasingly strains conventional rules, and suggested identifying whoever has effective control of a protocol. South African and other African traders who use automated strategies on Ethereum operate in the same open environment that this case exposed.
