Crypto Guru
MarketsFull story · 3 min read

S&P keeps Tether's USDT at weakest stability score as riskier reserves reach 28%

S&P Global Ratings left USDT on 5, the bottom of its five-point stablecoin stability scale, in an 18 November review. It found that gold, bitcoin, shares, secured loans and corporate bonds backed 28% of tokens in circulation at 30 September, up from 24% a year earlier, and flagged gaps in disclosure. Tether rejected the finding, saying S&P's framework rather than its reserves is the problem, and points to about $7.95 billion (about R137 billion) of assets above its liabilities.

The world's largest stablecoin has again landed at the bottom of S&P Global Ratings' scale. In a review dated 18 November, the ratings agency kept Tether's USDT on a stability score of 5, which it labels weak, the same result it gave a year ago. USDT is a token meant to be worth exactly one US dollar, and with a market value of roughly $175 billion (about R3 trillion) it is a core settlement asset for exchanges and trading desks around the world. S&P's score is not a credit rating and makes no call on where any price is heading; it is the agency's view of how well a stablecoin is likely to hold its dollar value.

What S&P looked at

S&P's main concern is what sits behind the tokens. According to Cointelegraph, assets the agency treats as higher risk, namely gold, bitcoin, listed shares, secured loans and corporate bonds, covered 28% of USDT in circulation at 30 September. A year earlier the share was 24%. The agency warned that a sharp fall in the value of those holdings could leave USDT short of full backing, a risk that would also spill over to the exchanges and DeFi protocols that rely on it to settle trades.

The agency also pointed to how Tether is supervised and how much it publishes. Tether is licensed in El Salvador, and S&P noted that the local rules from the CNAD regulator allow relatively risky assets to count towards reserves and do not require them to be held separately from the company's own assets. The reports Tether publishes do not name its custodians or trading counterparties, they come out quarterly where several rivals report monthly, and the audited financial statements behind them have not been made public, DigitalToday reported. S&P did credit USDT with keeping a steady price over the past year.

One detail shows how close to the floor the assessment is: S&P said it made no further downward adjustment only because its scale cannot go below 5.

Tether's answer

Tether pushed back hard. Its most recent reserve report, checked by accounting firm BDO, shows about $191.5 billion (about R3.3 trillion) of assets against about $183.5 billion (about R3.2 trillion) of liabilities, leaving an excess of roughly $7.95 billion (about R137 billion). The company invoked the film The Big Short, about the 2008 mortgage crisis, to question the ratings industry's own record, and told Cointelegraph that "The problem is S&P's framework, not our reserves." KPMG gave an unqualified audit opinion on Tether's 2025 accounts in August, Cointelegraph noted.

What the score does and doesn't mean

Neither side is disputing that Tether currently reports more assets than tokens. The argument is about quality and transparency: whether a cushion of a few billion dollars is enough when more than a quarter of backing sits in assets whose prices can swing, and whether holders can see enough to judge. The score does not stop anyone from holding or trading USDT, and it is not a forecast of a de-peg. It is one more input for exchanges, banks and regulators that are deciding which dollar tokens to accept, and S&P's critics, Tether chief among them, argue that its method undervalues a large excess buffer.

WHAT IT MEANS FOR AFRICA

Dollar stablecoins matter more in Africa than in most regions. Chainalysis found that stablecoin value received through peer-to-peer channels in Sub-Saharan Africa rose from $2.3 billion in 2022 to $14.6 billion (about R252 billion) in the year to June 2026, and that South Africa's crypto activity grew 52% to $39.3 billion (about R678 billion), led by cross-border peer-to-peer stablecoin flows, according to its regional report. Chainalysis does not break those figures down by token, so how much of that activity runs on USDT specifically is not reported.

Regulators on the continent are already writing their own tests for which tokens may circulate. Under Nigeria's central bank rules in force since 5 November, a foreign dollar stablecoin such as USDT can only be offered to Nigerians once the bank approves it and a Nigerian-incorporated issuer holds a licence; none had been granted, so existing arrangements need interim permission, Techpoint Africa reported. Kenya's new rules require stablecoin issuers to keep at least 30% of proceeds in local bank trust accounts, as Crypto Guru reported today. South Africa has no dedicated stablecoin licence yet, while rand-pegged tokens such as ZARU, backed by Luno, EasyEquities, Lesaka and Sanlam, are already live, TechCentral reported. S&P's review gives these regulators a ready-made checklist on reserve quality, segregation and disclosure, though none has said it will rely on it.

SOURCES

MORE FROM CRYPTO GURU

← All the latest crypto news